Return to Starlight Bay: Similar series
Cranberry Inn
by Beth Ehemann
4.24 · 68 ratings
sports · adult · new-adult · children · female-mc · humor · fiction · womens-fiction · family · contemporary · audiobook · multi-pov · small-town · athlete · kind-mc · romance · steamy · book · celebrity · drama
All books in this series ❯
Battered Hearts
by Kele Moon
3.97 · 60 ratings
small-town · family · war · drama · action-adventure · fiction · dark · new-adult · violent-conflict · romance · book · steamy · sports · angst · athlete · suspense · fighter · contemporary · multi-pov · alpha-mc
All books in this series ❯
Copper Valley Fireballs
by Pippa Grant
4.42 · 55 ratings
new-adult · adult · womens-fiction · fiction · celebrity · humor · small-town · contemporary · audiobook · sports · steamy · book · romance · comedy · grumpy-mc · family · slow-burn · enemies-to-lovers · athlete · forced-proximity
All books in this series ❯
Playing to Win
by Bella Matthews
4.24 · 66 ratings
adult · new-adult · fiction · friends-to-lovers · found-family · contemporary · book · sports · romance · age-gap · forced-proximity · multi-pov · billionaire · insta-love · humor · small-town · marriage-of-convenience · athlete · steamy · cheerful-mc
All books in this series ❯
The Blackhawk Boys
by Lexi Ryan
4.15 · 62 ratings
athlete · multi-pov · audiobook · contemporary · friends-to-lovers · romance · sports · book · new-adult · fiction · small-town · angst · university · drama · suspense · betrayal · alpha-mc · abuse · young-adult · dark
All books in this series ❯
Gravity
by Sarina Bowen
3.79 · 52 ratings
adult · romance · new-adult · fiction · contemporary · multi-pov · sports · book · womens-fiction · friends-to-lovers · audiobook · athlete · medical · mental-illness · drama · family · small-town · angst · steamy · realistic
All books in this series ❯
Fever Falls
by Riley Hart
4.18 · 62 ratings
contemporary · small-town · friends-to-lovers · romance · book · mlm · adult · lgbtq · fiction · humor · audiobook · steamy · drama · family · multi-pov · sports · fake-relationship · athlete · enemies-to-lovers · slow-burn
All books in this series ❯
Defiant Kings
by Bella Matthews
4.36 · 58 ratings
forced-proximity · billionaire · contemporary · book · romance · adult · fiction · sports · steamy · family · grumpy-sunshine · athlete · cheerful-mc · new-adult · grumpy-mc · coming-of-age · small-town · friends-to-lovers · second-chances · slow-burn
All books in this series ❯
Lost Stars
by Emery Rose
4.32 · 57 ratings
fiction · contemporary · romance · book · new-adult · multi-pov · friends-to-lovers · steamy · angst · epic · high-school · adult · slow-burn · drama · female-mc · small-town · sports · abuse · young-adult · age-gap
All books in this series ❯
The Elmwood Stories
by Lane Hayes
4.22 · 64 ratings
romance · adult · fiction · lgbtq · bisexuality · small-town · contemporary · athlete · mlm · sports · book · audiobook · multi-pov · steamy · grumpy-mc · friends-to-lovers · grumpy-sunshine · cheerful-mc · second-chances · age-gap
All books in this series ❯
Hometown Players
by Victoria Denault
4.14 · 42 ratings
book · sports · romance · fiction · new-adult · adult · contemporary · friends-to-lovers · female-author · university · athlete · small-town · audiobook · family · female-mc · enemies-to-lovers · children · billionaire
All books in this series ❯
Vegas Aces: The Wide Receiver
by Lisa Suzanne
4.44 · 50 ratings
adult · new-adult · small-town · contemporary · multi-pov · drama · sports · steamy · book · suspense · romance · fiction · celebrity · mystery · angst · friends-to-lovers · slow-burn · athlete · alpha-mc · betrayal
All books in this series ❯
Varsity Dads
by Lex Martin
4.21 · 48 ratings
new-adult · adult · fiction · contemporary · book · sports · romance · drama · university · poc-mc · athlete · friends-to-lovers · small-town · angst · forbidden-love · forced-proximity · multi-pov · second-chances · slow-burn · fake-relationship
All books in this series ❯
Oleander Springs
by Mariah Dietz
4.26 · 38 ratings
fiction · book · sports · romance · university · adult · new-adult · friends-to-lovers · contemporary · coming-of-age · slow-burn · small-town · disability · multi-pov · athlete · fake-relationship · suspense · grumpy-sunshine · kind-mc · friendship
All books in this series ❯
South Rock High
by A.J. Truman
4.11 · 38 ratings
mlm · book · sports · romance · small-town · contemporary · humor · fiction · lgbtq · adult · friends-to-lovers · found-family · athlete · workplace · multi-pov · enemies-to-lovers · fake-relationship · friendship · male-author · cheerful-mc
All books in this series ❯
Love in Maple Falls
by Grace Worthington
4.20 · 46 ratings
small-town · contemporary · religion · book · sports · romance · humor · fiction · spirituality · womens-fiction · adult · season-autumn · celebrity · washington · athlete · young-adult · north-america · usa · washington-dc · friends-to-lovers
All books in this series ❯
Fixer Brothers Construction Co.
by Raleigh Ruebins
4.24 · 62 ratings
lgbtq · fiction · adult · romance · book · mlm · contemporary · age-gap · small-town · friends-to-lovers · sports · athlete · workplace · humor · fake-relationship · bisexuality · celebrity · holidays · comedy · insta-love
All books in this series ❯
Kensley Panthers
by Nicole Dykes
4.11 · 44 ratings
mlm · romance · book · steamy · small-town · fiction · lgbtq · cheerful-mc · sports · contemporary · grumpy-sunshine · grumpy-mc · friends-to-lovers · enemies-to-lovers · adult · new-adult · angst · young-adult · multi-pov · forced-proximity
All books in this series ❯
Woodsmen Football
by Jamie Bennett
3.90 · 62 ratings
romance · sports · book · contemporary · fiction · adult · small-town · slow-burn · athlete · friends-to-lovers · humor · new-adult · kind-mc · cheerful-mc · grumpy-sunshine · workplace · womens-fiction · male-mc · grumpy-mc · angst
All books in this series ❯
Callahan Family
by Carrie Aarons
4.26 · 42 ratings
contemporary · romance · sports · adult · fiction · small-town · book · athlete · age-gap · workplace · multi-pov · friends-to-lovers · alpha-mc · enemies-to-lovers · female-mc · billionaire · suspense · grumpy-sunshine · box-set · secret-child
All books in this series ❯
Branston Bandits
by Piper James
4.15 · 20 ratings
romance · sports · book · fiction · humor · contemporary · adult · steamy · athlete · audiobook · small-town · friends-to-lovers · alpha-mc · new-adult · enemies-to-lovers · comedy · forced-proximity
All books in this series ❯
Gods of Hatherley Hall
by Becca Steele
4.12 · 17 ratings
suspense · enemies-to-lovers · multi-pov · contemporary · romance · literary-fiction · book · steamy · sports · new-adult · high-school · adult · drama · crime · mystery · fiction · athlete · friends-to-lovers · small-town · angst
All books in this series ❯
Love & Legacy
by Bella Matthews
4.53 · 15 ratings
fiction · romance · book · sports · contemporary · small-town · adult · forced-proximity · athlete · new-adult · organized-crime · steamy · family · fighter · multi-pov · billionaire · crime · friends-to-lovers · fake-relationship · blackmail
All books in this series ❯
Thornwood
by Caitlin Ricci
3.00 · 4 ratings
romance · book · adult · lgbtq · fiction · mlm · sports · athlete · new-adult · university · small-town · law-enforcement · contemporary
All books in this series ❯