The Witches of Wayward Bay
by Sarah Piper
4.00 · 2 ratings
audiobook · small-town · found-family · forced-proximity · magic · demons · paranormal · enemies-to-lovers · dark · adult · supernatural · witches-wizards · humor · fantasy · fiction · romance · book
The Witches of Wayward Bay: Similar series
All The Pretty Monsters
by Kristy Cunning
4.41 · 206 ratings
fiction · humor · mystery · witches-wizards · fantasy · female-mc · monsters · age-gap · slow-burn · adult · magic · polyamory · demons · dark · new-adult · harem · vampires · supernatural · ghosts · urban-fantasy
All books in this series ❯
The Fae Chronicles
by Amelia Hutchins
4.22 · 235 ratings
fiction · female-mc · fantasy · witches-wizards · dark · demons · new-adult · magic · book · steamy · romance · royalty · urban-fantasy · fae · supernatural · enemies-to-lovers · vampires · suspense · paranormal · alpha-mc
All books in this series ❯
Supernatural Battle: Werewolf Dens
by Kelly St. Clare
4.22 · 95 ratings
magic · new-adult · fantasy · action-adventure · fiction · female-mc · forbidden-love · slow-burn · age-gap · fated-mates · alpha-mc · small-town · contemporary · audiobook · enemies-to-lovers · suspense · paranormal · supernatural · urban-fantasy · vampires
All books in this series ❯
Lords of the Underworld
by Gena Showalter
4.23 · 1048 ratings
fiction · romance · supernatural · paranormal · fantasy · demons · myths · angels · magic · steamy · urban-fantasy · contemporary · adult · gods · vampires · alpha-mc · action-adventure · immortality · audiobook · book
All books in this series ❯
The Dark Side
by Kristy Cunning
4.18 · 160 ratings
paranormal · supernatural · romance · book · reverse-harem · polyamory · fiction · humor · myths · audiobook · contemporary · alpha-mc · angels · ghosts · harem · urban-fantasy · royalty · steamy · adult · magic
All books in this series ❯
Green Creek
by T.J. Klune
4.43 · 179 ratings
fiction · supernatural · urban-fantasy · angst · book · romance · magic · fantasy · family · lgbtq · contemporary · audiobook · paranormal · mlm · shapeshifters · new-adult · witches-wizards · adult · dark · sad
All books in this series ❯
Leveling Up
by K.F. Breene
4.49 · 253 ratings
fiction · fantasy · mythical-creatures · humor · magic · adult · vampires · supernatural · urban-fantasy · shapeshifters · book · romance · audiobook · contemporary · paranormal · witches-wizards · action-adventure · female-mc · alpha-mc · friendship
All books in this series ❯
Dark in You
by Suzanne Wright
4.30 · 230 ratings
book · paranormal · fiction · adult · supernatural · romance · demons · urban-fantasy · fantasy · magic · shapeshifters · steamy · alpha-mc · contemporary · action-adventure · humor · female-mc · fated-mates · new-adult · audiobook
All books in this series ❯
Rainshadow
by Jayne Castle
4.12 · 90 ratings
audiobook · contemporary · paranormal · suspense · ghosts · supernatural · book · urban-fantasy · romance · magic · adult · aliens · action-adventure · fiction · mystery · psychics · fantasy · family · futuristic · womens-fiction
All books in this series ❯
Wolves of Crimson Hollow
by M.H. Soars
4.09 · 64 ratings
reverse-harem · polyamory · shapeshifters · adult · magic · new-adult · female-mc · witches-wizards · fantasy · fiction · womens-fiction · fated-mates · audiobook · alpha-mc · suspense · paranormal · supernatural · romance · book · dark
All books in this series ❯
Emerald Lakes
by Britt Andrews
4.33 · 96 ratings
fiction · fantasy · polyamory · adult · magic · demons · supernatural · urban-fantasy · romance · reverse-harem · book · small-town · paranormal · enemies-to-lovers · witches-wizards · fated-mates · lgbtq · new-adult · dark · mlm
All books in this series ❯
Wrath & Rain
by Nikki St. Crowe
4.04 · 47 ratings
enemies-to-lovers · witches-wizards · fiction · fantasy · magic · demons · new-adult · vampires · supernatural · urban-fantasy · romance · steamy · book · myths · alpha-mc · paranormal · female-mc · action-adventure · adult · dark
All books in this series ❯
Charming Cove
by Linsey Hall
4.07 · 45 ratings
humor · fantasy · fiction · witches-wizards · magic · magical-realism · book · romance · small-town · forced-proximity · contemporary · cozy · paranormal · womens-fiction · slow-burn · adult · urban-fantasy · supernatural · enemies-to-lovers · fake-relationship
All books in this series ❯
Supernatural Bounty Hunter
by Leia Stone
4.11 · 44 ratings
romance · adult · magic · asian-mc · comedy · demons · fiction · fantasy · humor · witches-wizards · poc-mc · paranormal · vampires · supernatural · urban-fantasy · shapeshifters · steamy · book · hell · mystery
All books in this series ❯
Demon Magic
by Alice Winters
4.37 · 68 ratings
lgbtq · witches-wizards · fiction · fantasy · action-adventure · humor · demons · adult · magic · romance · book · mlm · supernatural · urban-fantasy · paranormal · mystery · shapeshifters · vampires · suspense · contemporary
All books in this series ❯
Supernatural Singles
by April Asher
3.94 · 38 ratings
womens-fiction · witches-wizards · fantasy · fiction · magic · adult · romance · book · supernatural · paranormal · contemporary · forced-proximity · fated-mates · family · humor · demons · shapeshifters · urban-fantasy · enemies-to-lovers · angels
All books in this series ❯
Mismatched Mates
by Eliot Grayson
3.98 · 125 ratings
magic · fantasy · lgbtq · paranormal · mlm · shapeshifters · adult · fiction · romance · contemporary · urban-fantasy · book · action-adventure · omegaverse · forced-proximity · abuse · supernatural · vampires · witches-wizards · steamy
All books in this series ❯
The Vein Chronicles
by Anne Malcom
4.09 · 44 ratings
drama · witches-wizards · fiction · fantasy · humor · dark · new-adult · adult · magic · romance · shapeshifters · book · vampires · supernatural · paranormal · anti-hero · audiobook · alpha-mc · female-mc · action-adventure
All books in this series ❯
Demons of New Chicago
by Kel Carpenter
4.05 · 40 ratings
fantasy · fiction · witches-wizards · magic · adult · demons · supernatural · urban-fantasy · book · paranormal · humor · ghosts · vampires · shapeshifters · romance · dystopia · audiobook · myths · action-adventure · female-mc
All books in this series ❯
Chosen Champions
by Macy Blake
4.43 · 47 ratings
contemporary · paranormal · mlm · romance · book · shapeshifters · magic · adult · fantasy · fiction · lgbtq · dragons · supernatural · urban-fantasy · vampires · fae · action-adventure · family · audiobook · mystery
All books in this series ❯
The Mate Games
by K. Loraine
4.26 · 34 ratings
paranormal · audiobook · reverse-harem · book · scandinavia · shapeshifters · steamy · romance · vampires · supernatural · urban-fantasy · adult · polyamory · europe · fiction · fantasy · witches-wizards · enemies-to-lovers · contemporary · fae
All books in this series ❯
Grave Concerns
by Jayce Carter
4.17 · 24 ratings
magic · romance · book · steamy · reverse-harem · shapeshifters · supernatural · urban-fantasy · vampires · paranormal · witches-wizards · fantasy · fiction · demons · polyamory · adult · ghosts · fae · dragons · alpha-mc
All books in this series ❯
Monsters of St. Mark's
by K.C. Cross
4.29 · 24 ratings
shapeshifters · adult · fantasy · supernatural · romance · fiction · ancient-civilization · mystery · audiobook · magic · monsters · paranormal · enemies-to-lovers · dragons · myths · book · gods · humor · historical · demons
All books in this series ❯
The Hunter and the Spider
by E.M. Jeanmougin
4.00 · 8 ratings
mlm · supernatural · urban-fantasy · vampires · romance · book · shapeshifters · disability · paranormal · fantasy · action-adventure · fiction · lgbtq · adult · demons · enemies-to-lovers · age-gap · magic · revenge · kidnapping
All books in this series ❯