Once Bitten, Twice Shy: Similar romance series

The Bargainer

by Laura Thalassa

4.03 · 309 ratings

fantasy · fiction · supernatural · fae · romance · steamy · paranormal · urban-fantasy · royalty · book · audiobook · contemporary · myths · anti-hero · mystery · fated-mates · age-gap · magic · dark · new-adult

All books in this series ❯

The Dark Elements

by Jennifer L. Armentrout

4.19 · 204 ratings

supernatural · urban-fantasy · young-adult · paranormal · fantasy · fiction · demons · magic · romance · alpha-mc · female-mc · action-adventure · humor · book · shapeshifters · angels · contemporary · myths · love-triangle · mythical-creatures

All books in this series ❯

Supernatural Academy

by Jaymin Eve

4.31 · 99 ratings

young-adult · new-adult · high-school · polyamory · magic · gods · university · fated-mates · female-mc · humor · fantasy · fiction · paranormal · audiobook · contemporary · myths · alpha-mc · romance · book · reverse-harem

All books in this series ❯

Supernatural Prison

by Jaymin Eve

4.27 · 94 ratings

romance · reverse-harem · shapeshifters · book · fae · vampires · supernatural · urban-fantasy · young-adult · paranormal · dragons · audiobook · friends-to-lovers · alpha-mc · witches-wizards · female-mc · fiction · action-adventure · humor · fantasy

All books in this series ❯

Fallen Academy

by Leia Stone

4.25 · 152 ratings

fantasy · fiction · new-adult · demons · magic · book · shapeshifters · romance · young-adult · supernatural · urban-fantasy · angels · paranormal · audiobook · gods · futuristic · female-mc · post-apocalyptic · vampires · alpha-mc

All books in this series ❯

Relentless

by Karen Lynch

4.43 · 229 ratings

fiction · fantasy · magic · romance · book · urban-fantasy · vampires · young-adult · paranormal · fated-mates · new-adult · demons · supernatural · fae · audiobook · alpha-mc · action-adventure · shapeshifters · female-mc · witches-wizards

All books in this series ❯

Seraph Black

by Jane Washington

4.22 · 105 ratings

young-adult · supernatural · harem · book · urban-fantasy · reverse-harem · romance · alpha-mc · audiobook · contemporary · suspense · paranormal · mystery · fantasy · fiction · slow-burn · fated-mates · magic · polyamory · high-school

All books in this series ❯

Supernatural Prison Story

by Jaymin Eve

4.38 · 98 ratings

audiobook · dragons · paranormal · supernatural · urban-fantasy · fae · vampires · book · shapeshifters · romance · magic · new-adult · fantasy · fiction · witches-wizards · friends-to-lovers · young-adult · demons · fated-mates · alpha-mc

All books in this series ❯

Secret Keepers

by Jaymin Eve

4.21 · 118 ratings

new-adult · high-school · fantasy · aliens · fiction · paranormal · urban-fantasy · young-adult · romance · book · reverse-harem · shapeshifters · polyamory · magic · dragons · supernatural · insta-love · fated-mates · billionaire · other-world

All books in this series ❯

Harem of Hearts

by C.M. Stunich

4.16 · 56 ratings

angels · dragons · enemies-to-lovers · paranormal · reverse-harem · shapeshifters · book · steamy · romance · royalty · vampires · harem · urban-fantasy · fairy-tale · supernatural · retellings · dark · new-adult · magic · horror

All books in this series ❯

The Veil Diaries

by B.L. Brunnemer

4.40 · 186 ratings

paranormal · friends-to-lovers · romance · reverse-harem · book · necromancy · ghosts · supernatural · urban-fantasy · young-adult · new-adult · high-school · polyamory · magic · slow-burn · fiction · fantasy · contemporary · audiobook · witches-wizards

All books in this series ❯

Star-Crossed

by Rachel Higginson

4.18 · 165 ratings

paranormal · young-adult · romance · book · shapeshifters · witches-wizards · fiction · fantasy · audiobook · urban-fantasy · magic · supernatural · contemporary · alpha-mc · royalty · new-adult · high-school · female-mc · action-adventure · angst

All books in this series ❯

Evermore Academy

by Audrey Grey

4.09 · 54 ratings

romance · shapeshifters · book · angst · fae · supernatural · urban-fantasy · vampires · royalty · paranormal · young-adult · enemies-to-lovers · audiobook · dystopia · fated-mates · fiction · fantasy · new-adult · magic · boarding-school

All books in this series ❯

My Pack

by Lane Whitt

4.08 · 52 ratings

contemporary · audiobook · multi-pov · alpha-mc · paranormal · abuse · supernatural · harem · royalty · urban-fantasy · romance · steamy · book · reverse-harem · shapeshifters · polyamory · new-adult · fantasy · fiction · age-gap

All books in this series ❯

Matefinder

by Leia Stone

4.09 · 66 ratings

book · shapeshifters · vampires · paranormal · fated-mates · fantasy · fiction · magic · romance · supernatural · urban-fantasy · young-adult · suspense · audiobook · alpha-mc · witches-wizards · action-adventure · new-adult · contemporary · dark

All books in this series ❯

The Evelyn Maynard Trilogy

by Kaydence Snow

4.28 · 82 ratings

fated-mates · fiction · fantasy · new-adult · polyamory · magic · romance · reverse-harem · supernatural · urban-fantasy · paranormal · enemies-to-lovers · university · steamy · book · contemporary · age-gap · slow-burn · alpha-mc · action-adventure

All books in this series ❯

War of the Covens

by Samantha Young

4.07 · 61 ratings

supernatural · young-adult · urban-fantasy · high-school · demons · dark · new-adult · magic · drama · gods · fiction · fantasy · action-adventure · love-triangle · mystery · witches-wizards · female-mc · paranormal · alpha-mc · contemporary

All books in this series ❯