Bachelors of Buttermilk Falls: Similar romance series

The Phoenix Pack

by Suzanne Wright

4.14 · 262 ratings

suspense · paranormal · alpha-mc · contemporary · audiobook · multi-pov · steamy · book · shapeshifters · romance · supernatural · urban-fantasy · new-adult · magic · drama · fated-mates · fantasy · action-adventure · fiction · humor

All books in this series ❯

The Mercury Pack

by Suzanne Wright

4.20 · 158 ratings

multi-pov · audiobook · contemporary · alpha-mc · suspense · paranormal · supernatural · urban-fantasy · romance · steamy · book · shapeshifters · adult · magic · new-adult · female-mc · fantasy · action-adventure · fiction · humor

All books in this series ❯

Mageri

by Dannika Dark

4.25 · 267 ratings

urban-fantasy · supernatural · magic · fiction · witches-wizards · fantasy · paranormal · shapeshifters · romance · vampires · audiobook · book · new-adult · mystery · urban · contemporary · dark · psychics · alpha-mc · ghosts

All books in this series ❯

Naked Werewolf

by Molly Harper

3.95 · 77 ratings

romance · shapeshifters · book · steamy · vampires · supernatural · urban-fantasy · paranormal · suspense · contemporary · audiobook · small-town · alpha-mc · womens-fiction · fiction · fantasy · humor · mystery · comedy · adult

All books in this series ❯

The Lazy Girl's Guide to Magic

by Helen Harper

4.14 · 111 ratings

fantasy · fiction · book · urban-fantasy · womens-fiction · humor · mystery · witches-wizards · comedy · new-adult · magic · romance · supernatural · paranormal · contemporary · audiobook · crime · animals · action-adventure · female-mc

All books in this series ❯

Enchanted, Inc.

by Shanna Swendson

3.94 · 244 ratings

urban-fantasy · magic · womens-fiction · fiction · fantasy · paranormal · witches-wizards · romance · supernatural · humor · mythical-creatures · audiobook · contemporary · book · fae · mystery · cozy · comedy · magical-realism · action-adventure

All books in this series ❯

Ghosts and Reincarnation

by Kristen Ashley

4.19 · 108 ratings

ghosts · supernatural · adult · magic · drama · family · womens-fiction · fiction · fantasy · humor · mystery · paranormal · suspense · alpha-mc · billionaire · contemporary · audiobook · steamy · book · romance

All books in this series ❯

Glimmer Lake

by Elizabeth Hunter

4.36 · 64 ratings

small-town · womens-fiction · psychics · fantasy · mystery · fiction · magic · romance · book · supernatural · ghosts · urban-fantasy · cozy · suspense · paranormal · contemporary · audiobook · family · crime · female-mc

All books in this series ❯

Wicked Witches of the Midwest

by Amanda M. Lee

4.49 · 459 ratings

paranormal · cozy · book · supernatural · urban-fantasy · fiction · witches-wizards · mystery · magic · adult · fantasy · audiobook · ghosts · magical-realism · romance · womens-fiction · humor · contemporary · murder · comedy

All books in this series ❯

Frogmorton Farm

by Jodi Taylor

4.31 · 78 ratings

book · contemporary · audiobook · animals · womens-fiction · fiction · fantasy · humor · magical-realism · adult · romance · urban-fantasy · paranormal · mystery · comedy · time-travel · horses · supernatural · friendship · female-mc

All books in this series ❯

Dangerous Damsels

by India Holton

3.85 · 57 ratings

book · regency · romance · enemies-to-lovers · paranormal · industrial-era · fantasy · action-adventure · humor · mystery · fiction · witches-wizards · adult · magic · victorian · historical · historical-fiction · urban-fantasy · cozy · feminism

All books in this series ❯

Wicked Witches of the Midwest

by Amanda M. Lee

4.36 · 109 ratings

magical-realism · womens-fiction · fantasy · mystery · fiction · humor · witches-wizards · cozy · paranormal · contemporary · audiobook · book · romance · urban-fantasy · adult · magic · law-enforcement · supernatural · retellings · action-adventure

All books in this series ❯

Betwixt & Between

by Darynda Jones

4.31 · 72 ratings

urban-fantasy · supernatural · ghosts · book · shapeshifters · romance · contemporary · audiobook · paranormal · fantasy · humor · mystery · fiction · female-mc · witches-wizards · urban · womens-fiction · adult · magic · magical-realism

All books in this series ❯

Dove Pond

by Karen Hawkins

3.94 · 80 ratings

adult · contemporary · magical-realism · humor · paranormal · fantasy · fiction · book · womens-fiction · romance · magic · audiobook · small-town · female-mc · family · cozy · new-adult · supernatural · friendship · suspense

All books in this series ❯

A Wishcraft Mystery

by Heather Blake

4.15 · 138 ratings

magic · romance · book · supernatural · urban-fantasy · cozy · paranormal · audiobook · animals · female-mc · witches-wizards · fantasy · humor · fiction · murder · mystery · killer · contemporary · small-town · amateur-sleuth

All books in this series ❯

Nodaway Falls

by Lucy March

3.57 · 45 ratings

magical-realism · book · gothic · romance · audiobook · contemporary · paranormal · fantasy · humor · fiction · mystery · witches-wizards · womens-fiction · magic · adult · supernatural · urban-fantasy · cozy · family · ghosts

All books in this series ❯

Fred the Mermaid

by MaryJanice Davidson

3.75 · 60 ratings

myths · paranormal · urban-fantasy · supernatural · shapeshifters · romance · magic · action-adventure · fantasy · humor · fiction · love-triangle · womens-fiction · mermaids · contemporary · adult · military · comedy · mythical-creatures · urban

All books in this series ❯

Charming Cove

by Linsey Hall

4.07 · 45 ratings

book · romance · cozy · paranormal · forced-proximity · small-town · contemporary · fantasy · humor · fiction · witches-wizards · magical-realism · magic · urban-fantasy · supernatural · enemies-to-lovers · slow-burn · womens-fiction · adult · shapeshifters

All books in this series ❯

Lucy Valentine

by Heather Webber

3.98 · 87 ratings

fantasy · humor · fiction · mystery · paranormal · womens-fiction · adult · magical-realism · urban-fantasy · book · romance · contemporary · audiobook · cozy · psychics · female-mc · magic · supernatural · murder · crime

All books in this series ❯

The Witches of Thistle Grove

by Lana Harper

3.72 · 65 ratings

magic · season-autumn · magical-realism · spooky · witches-wizards · fiction · fantasy · lgbtq · contemporary · wlw · paranormal · urban-fantasy · romance · book · adult · humor · audiobook · small-town · new-adult · female-mc

All books in this series ❯

Supernatural Singles

by April Asher

3.94 · 38 ratings

magic · adult · fantasy · fiction · witches-wizards · womens-fiction · contemporary · paranormal · supernatural · book · romance · demons · humor · family · fated-mates · friends-to-lovers · forced-proximity · audiobook · enemies-to-lovers · angels

All books in this series ❯

Witching Hour

by Christine Zane Thomas

4.25 · 70 ratings

cozy · paranormal · supernatural · vampires · book · shapeshifters · adult · female-mc · witches-wizards · fantasy · mystery · fiction · animals · contemporary · urban-fantasy · magic · romance · humor · audiobook · angels

All books in this series ❯

Ghosted

by Sarah Ready

4.05 · 44 ratings

paranormal · audiobook · contemporary · book · romance · magical-realism · adult · fantasy · fiction · forced-proximity · billionaire · insta-love · new-adult · womens-fiction · humor · enemies-to-lovers · time-travel · sci-fi · domestic-drama · love-triangle

All books in this series ❯