Not Your Basic Witch: Similar romance series

Ruthless Boys of the Zodiac

by Caroline Peckham

4.44 · 177 ratings

fae · high-school · dark · new-adult · magic · polyamory · university · fated-mates · cruel-mc · mystery · humor · fiction · fantasy · dragons · enemies-to-lovers · paranormal · alpha-mc · steamy · book · reverse-harem

All books in this series ❯

Supernatural Prison

by Jaymin Eve

4.27 · 94 ratings

female-mc · witches-wizards · fantasy · action-adventure · humor · fiction · polyamory · magic · new-adult · urban-fantasy · supernatural · vampires · fae · young-adult · romance · book · reverse-harem · audiobook · shapeshifters · alpha-mc

All books in this series ❯

Kit Davenport

by Tate James

4.31 · 219 ratings

paranormal · reverse-harem · shapeshifters · romance · supernatural · urban-fantasy · magic · fiction · fantasy · dragons · steamy · polyamory · book · dark · new-adult · military · action-adventure · humor · outlaws · suspense

All books in this series ❯

The Veil Diaries

by B.L. Brunnemer

4.40 · 186 ratings

paranormal · friends-to-lovers · romance · reverse-harem · book · necromancy · ghosts · supernatural · urban-fantasy · young-adult · new-adult · high-school · polyamory · magic · slow-burn · fiction · fantasy · contemporary · audiobook · witches-wizards

All books in this series ❯

Phoenix Rising

by Quinn Arthurs

4.27 · 117 ratings

polyamory · new-adult · fiction · fantasy · paranormal · mlm · reverse-harem · shapeshifters · book · romance · magic · psychics · fated-mates · university · urban-fantasy · steamy · lgbtq · slow-burn · multi-pov · supernatural

All books in this series ❯

Emerald Lakes

by Britt Andrews

4.33 · 96 ratings

fiction · fantasy · polyamory · adult · magic · demons · supernatural · urban-fantasy · romance · reverse-harem · book · small-town · paranormal · enemies-to-lovers · witches-wizards · fated-mates · lgbtq · new-adult · dark · mlm

All books in this series ❯

Her Guardians

by G. Bailey

4.19 · 74 ratings

urban-fantasy · supernatural · vampires · reverse-harem · shapeshifters · romance · angels · paranormal · fantasy · fiction · witches-wizards · magic · polyamory · demons · royalty · young-adult · book · fae · alpha-mc · audiobook

All books in this series ❯

New Moon

by Belle Harper

4.14 · 44 ratings

angels · paranormal · reverse-harem · shapeshifters · book · romance · young-adult · harem · mlm · supernatural · vampires · high-school · new-adult · magic · poverty · polyamory · fated-mates · age-gap · fiction · fantasy

All books in this series ❯

Hidden Kingdom

by L. Rose

4.11 · 54 ratings

paranormal · vampires · fae · book · reverse-harem · shapeshifters · urban-fantasy · romance · adult · magic · polyamory · fantasy · fiction · fated-mates · alpha-mc · audiobook · multi-pov · royalty · supernatural · mlm

All books in this series ❯

Dark River Days

by Grace McGinty

4.39 · 54 ratings

magic · romance · steamy · book · reverse-harem · supernatural · mlm · urban-fantasy · vampires · shapeshifters · paranormal · witches-wizards · fantasy · fiction · polyamory · adult · dragons · alpha-mc · disability · lgbtq

All books in this series ❯

Marked

by Cece Rose

4.05 · 60 ratings

romance · reverse-harem · paranormal · fantasy · fiction · polyamory · magic · steamy · book · supernatural · urban-fantasy · young-adult · witches-wizards · harem · shapeshifters · audiobook · new-adult · boarding-school · multi-pov · alpha-mc

All books in this series ❯

Darkest Flames

by Katie May

4.20 · 44 ratings

book · reverse-harem · romance · young-adult · stalking · supernatural · urban-fantasy · enemies-to-lovers · paranormal · fated-mates · humor · fantasy · fiction · high-school · dark · demons · polyamory · horror · revenge · angels

All books in this series ❯

Midnight Fae Academy

by Lexi C. Foss

4.28 · 64 ratings

romance · book · reverse-harem · fae · vampires · paranormal · fiction · fantasy · polyamory · magic · steamy · urban-fantasy · royalty · multi-pov · audiobook · adult · mlm · enemies-to-lovers · new-adult · supernatural

All books in this series ❯

Willow's Forbidden Pack

by Avery Song

4.40 · 42 ratings

fiction · fantasy · witches-wizards · crime · fated-mates · magic · polyamory · dark · mlm · supernatural · reverse-harem · book · steamy · shapeshifters · urban-fantasy · romance · myths · paranormal · suspense · female-mc

All books in this series ❯

Hemlock Academy

by Kelsey Soliz

4.19 · 70 ratings

fated-mates · humor · fantasy · fiction · new-adult · polyamory · romance · book · reverse-harem · paranormal · adult · contemporary · gods · magic · shapeshifters · mlm · supernatural · vampires · university · witches-wizards

All books in this series ❯