Books like 'Tenderly Bewitched'
Readers who enjoyed Tenderly Bewitched by Lyra Winters also liked the following books featuring the same tropes, story themes, relationship dynamics and character types.
romance fantasy fated-mates witches-wizards reverse-harem polyamory paranormal stalking multi-pov dark
-
Taming the Beast by Alicia Montgomery
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 12 ratings**Can be read as a standalone werewolf billionaire shifter paranormal romance book**The True Mates Series continues as billionaire CEO security expert Sebastian Creed battles his inner beast while trying to keep his desire for genius scientist Dr. Jade Cross from destroying them both. Shy and nerdy Lycan scientist Dr. Jade Cross has lived a quiet life, surrounded by her work and her research...Categorized as:
fated-mates paranormal polyamory reverse-harem witches-wizards adult billionaire book -
![The Faerie Wand by Michelle Madow]()
The Faerie Wand by Michelle Madow
Rated: 4.36 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsI thought I could return home once the Faerie Games were over. I was wrong. Now, Julian and I must complete the dangerous quest given to us by the Empress of the Otherworld. The Holy Wand is out there. We just need to find it. No matter where the journey takes us, we'll destroy anything blocking our path. We have to. Otherwise, we'll be dead. Romance. Magic. Adventure... -
![Fight Little Wolf by Serenity Rayne]()
Fight Little Wolf by Serenity Rayne
Rated: 4.40 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsMy name is Aurora and this is my journey. I have traveled far, hunting down my enemies. What I've learned so far hurts, the betrayal runs bone deep. So many cogs in the machine, and so many traitors to pursue. The ice dragon castle is a place of wonder and great danger. I settle two scores and receive a surprising arrival. Oberon, King of the High Elves takes an interest in my journey...Categorized as:
reverse-harem paranormal fated-mates multi-pov polyamory romance shapeshifters dragons -
![Hawk's Heart by J.L. Madore]()
Hawk's Heart by J.L. Madore
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 12 ratingsThis is an alternate cover edition for ASIN B08F323CMXThe Phoenix has Risen. Things are getting hot.The quint is aligned and as much as I hoped life would simplify once the five of us mated... it's a big 'Hells No' on that.Don't get me wrong, the guys are great, with me, with each other... -
-
![The Fae Princes by Nikki St. Crowe]()
The Fae Princes by Nikki St. Crowe
Rated: 4.35 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsI thought Peter Pan was a myth and Neverland a fairytale. A story spun by my mother who had lost her mind a long time ago.But there was no denying the overwhelming shadow cast by Peter Pan when he was standing in my house.Pan took me captive to Neverland and I somehow found my place among him and the Lost Boys.I’ve never looked back... -
![Realm of Flames by M. Sinclair]()
Realm of Flames by M. Sinclair
Rated: 4.38 of 5 stars · 21 ratingsWe were leaving Earth and traveling to an entirely new realm… well, new for me.The Dreki realm. Before escaping Louisiana with my mother and meeting my mates, I’d lived trapped like a bird inside of a cage of Pastor Malcolm’s creation. I was free now. I was also starting to realize what that meant for myself, my mates, and my identity as a shifter... -
![Soul Of The Shayde by Lili Zander]()
Soul Of The Shayde by Lili Zander
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsThe vampires of Shayde want more than just my blood… We’ve reached the point of no-return. Everywhere we look, death surrounds us. Thousands of vampires dead. Billions more at risk. The Empire is on the brink of a catastrophe. And only Ragnar, Saber, Zeke, Nero, and I can stop it. The stakes have never been higher. But we cannot turn away. We’re fighting for the soul of the Shayde... -
![Aurora by M.J. Marstens]()
Aurora by M.J. Marstens
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsI don’t believe in witches, spells, fated mates, and I sure as hell don’t believe in ice skating! I hate cold weather, snow, and ice. Nothing is making me visit Silver Springs...BUT—there’s always a ‘but’—apparently, three unsuspecting men trespass upon a cranky old witch’s territory and we’re talking 'hasn’t had her morning brew' cranky... -
![Catching Eagles by Kelsey Soliz]()
Catching Eagles by Kelsey Soliz
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsI finally found my mate from the Desert Hills territory, after walking nearly the entire length of its borders.The problem is, he doesn't count.There's a clause in the magical guide to mates that if a partner isn't from your world, they can't represent a territory... -
![Dinosaurs, Dilemmas & Albert Einswine by Sedona Ashe]()
Dinosaurs, Dilemmas & Albert Einswine by Sedona Ashe
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsWhoever said diamonds are a girl’s best friend, got it wrong.It turns out, bones are a girl’s best friend. Not that kind of bone… get your mind out of the gutter.We’d arrived at the museum, and everything was going well. Okay, fine. That’s a lie...Categorized as:
reverse-harem paranormal fated-mates polyamory romance shapeshifters mythical-creatures fantasy -
![Magic in the Moonlight by Auryn Hadley]()
Magic in the Moonlight by Auryn Hadley
Rated: 4.38 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsSugar, spice, and everything nice, that's what witches' spells should be made of...Running to Summerpoint to avoid my failed love life may have seemed drastic, but I'd just inherited a house from a distant relative. The timing was perfect, almost like magic. But the cottage is in need of repairs, the place is in the middle of a forest, and I'm not used to small towns... -
![Birth of a Raven by M. Sinclair]()
Birth of a Raven by M. Sinclair
Rated: 4.38 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsBefore Vegas and her men joined the Red Masques, they were... the Ravens. Our small Midwestern town has always been a quiet, sleepy, and safe place to grow up in. My foster family has made our home here and I hadn’t expected anything different for our senior year of high school.But noise is being made in our small town. Suddenly, there are new people that have come to town... -
![Cursed Wolf by Angelica Aquiles]()
Cursed Wolf by Angelica Aquiles
Rated: 4.38 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsI’m racing against time. Benji’s shifting abilities aren’t helping him, and he needs a cure, or he’ll die. The council wants me dead, but the real threat to my life has nothing to do with them.Tyler is growing weaker trying to help Benji, and if they don’t make it out alive, I don’t think any of us will survive...Categorized as:
reverse-harem paranormal witches-wizards fated-mates polyamory romance shapeshifters urban-fantasy -
![Royal Mate by Eva Chase]()
Royal Mate by Eva Chase
Rated: 4.30 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsLove bound us together... but fate has other plans.Just when a happily ever after with my Seelie men was within reach, the Heart of the Mists tied me to one of the foreboding winter arch-lords. I can't escape the connection between us. The enemy can speak from right within my soul.I'm not willing to give up on my happiness that easily, but I can't let the realms descend into all-out war... -
-
![Pack Promised by J. Kearston]()
Pack Promised by J. Kearston
Rated: 4.30 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsThe wolves waiting in the wind are always watching.My life has never been normal. Raised by a survivalist, taught how to endure anything, I've learned to rely on myself. To keep my head down-- to mind my own business. That all changes in an instant when I hear the screams... -
![More Than I Can Bear by Sam Hall]()
More Than I Can Bear by Sam Hall
Rated: 4.30 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsThe hottest footballer in town is searching for the girl that got away. Me. We had one amazing night together, but when I woke up I knew I needed to get back to my boring life. But he refuses to take no for an answer. The whole city is looking for the girl with the custom painted Converse But I’ve got other problems. The guy who keeps coming into my cafe, who’s as grumpy as he is hot... -
![Shifted Rule by Elena Lawson]()
Shifted Rule by Elena Lawson
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 12 ratingsFool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice…I don’t think so.I hated Ryland from the start. Now that he’s my alpha, hate is nowhere near a strong enough word. I’m barely holding on as it is, I don’t need him barking orders at me every chance he gets.Layla and Viv aren’t speaking to me, and I mean, I can’t really blame them... -
![Born to be Witchy by A.J. Macey, Jarica James]()
Born to be Witchy by A.J. Macey, Jarica James
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsAris Calisto was not your basic witch in the world of Akasha; with pink hair, sass, and an unusual upbringing that gave her a unique perspective on things, she wouldn’t accept being held back forever. After many twists, turns, and uphill battles, Aris and her men finally have their happy ever after...Categorized as:
fated-mates multi-pov paranormal polyamory reverse-harem witches-wizards book fiction -
![Blood Of The Shayde by Lili Zander]()
Blood Of The Shayde by Lili Zander
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsThe vampires of Shayde want more than just my blood…One deadly human assassin sent to kill me.Two powerful vampire politicians, playing games with human lives.A gorgeous, terrifying, inscrutable prince who wants to claim me.Three deadly enemies. Three mortal threats.But I am not alone any more. I have Saber, Zeke, and Nero on my side. And together, we can do anything.Bring it on... -
![Liberating Water by Elizabeth Knight]()
Liberating Water by Elizabeth Knight
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsThe Elementi Knights have survived their first encounter with the Dark Lord, and one of his members of the Dark Army. They are now coming to the realization they are the only thing standing in the way of the dangers that are unraveling around them. The Day-Brite serum is missing and the Dark Lord is using it to build his army whose purpose is still unknown... -
![Fate by Elaina Jadin, Marie Robinson]()
Fate by Elaina Jadin, Marie Robinson
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsThe story of Fawn and the Blackfang Barons concludes in book three, Fate... -
![You're Cursed: Disaster Zone Jones Book Two by Kat Quinn]()
You're Cursed: Disaster Zone Jones Book Two by Kat Quinn
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsOkay, well, that's fine: everything's fine. Just turns out my ex-sorta-boyfriend is a crazy shadow creature stalker and has some sort of murder boner for me and my five new...boyfriends? Soul mates isn't something you just slip into casual conversation, but murder boner totally is. Other people have these problems too, right? The good news is we're all still alive... -
![Regent Witches by G. Bailey, Regan Rosewood]()
Regent Witches by G. Bailey, Regan Rosewood
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsMy powers are back, my men are safe, but the academy has a new enemy.And we are all at risk if we can't stop him. The days of being in foster care are long in the past and I have everything in the family I have found at the academy, but Hawthorne threatens everything. New powers, dangerous experiments and monsters rising from the shadows...we have never been in this much danger...Categorized as:
paranormal polyamory reverse-harem witches-wizards book dragons fiction shapeshifters -
![Destined to Lead by Sterling Thomas]()
Destined to Lead by Sterling Thomas
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsRejected. Banished. Packless. Alone. When the love of my life rejects me, I'm desperate to escape the wilds. Even if it means fleeing to the human cities. Shifters grow up hearing horror stories about humans treating us as nothing more than a nuisance at best and easy sport at worst...Categorized as:
fated-mates multi-pov paranormal polyamory reverse-harem witches-wizards action-adventure adult -
-
![Takeback by L.L. Frost]()
Takeback by L.L. Frost
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsAdie escaped the Hunters, but not without cost. Nightmares plague her sleep, questioning the choices she made. Or is it something more?Part 8 of Succubus Dreams.Join Adie on her (mis)adventures toward achieving a quasi-normal life among humans.A charming, slow-burn reverse harem serial about one reluctant succubus and the sexy demons determined to have her... -
![Our Blood by Brea Alepoú]()
Our Blood by Brea Alepoú
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsA coven isn’t a home without witches. Finnely is still dealing with the aftermath of losing all that he’s known. The guilt that eats at him every day is only pushed down by his men who give him purpose: A stalker vampire, an a-hole prince vampire, and a broken wolf.The humans are done turning a blind eye to the supernatural...Categorized as:
paranormal witches-wizards reverse-harem dark polyamory vampires shapeshifters magic -
![Relentless by Mysti Parker, Lindsey R. Loucks]()
Relentless by Mysti Parker, Lindsey R. Loucks
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsWren's fourth mate just might be the death of her...that is if the world doesn't end first.From USA Today bestselling author Lindsey R. Loucks and award-winning author Mysti Parker, get lost in a paranormal reverse harem series that will leave you breathless and begging for more!Wren, true heir to the vampire’s Southern Clan throne, has recently joined the Kidnapped Multiple Times Club... -
![Celine by Kira Stanley]()
Celine by Kira Stanley
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsI was a broken and discarded siren princess. The one who's voice called to no one. Left mateless, a disappointment to my mother, and an outcast among my people, I got off siren island and joined the supernatural task force for the CIA.Now, I went after bad guys and made sure they never saw the light of day. That was until some sadistic vampire smelled my blood and went a little blood crazed...Categorized as:
paranormal reverse-harem fated-mates witches-wizards dark polyamory romance shapeshifters -
![The Forest Witch Lies by Amber Nicole]()
The Forest Witch Lies by Amber Nicole
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsAn explosion takes everything from me. It should have been my ending, but it was only the beginning.A prophecy, a curse, and secrets are just the start.Alistar Academy was supposed to be a normal college right?Maybe for others but certainly not for me.Thrown into a world of mystery with lies hidden beneath the glamour.I find myself discovering satanic rituals, kidnappings, and bloodlines... -
![Swarmed: Succubus Dreams Serial by L.L. Frost]()
Swarmed: Succubus Dreams Serial by L.L. Frost
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsAdie escaped the Hunters, but not without cost. Nightmares plague her sleep, questioning the choices she made. Or is it something more? Part 7 of Succubus Dreams. Join Adie on her (mis)adventures toward achieving a quasi-normal life among humans. A charming, slow-burn reverse harem serial about one reluctant succubus and the sexy demons determined to have her... -
![Exposed by Crystal North]()
Exposed by Crystal North
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsEverything is about to be exposed.The four men in my complicated life are saying so.Everywhere I go on campus, girls seem to be dropping like flies and no one seems to notice. Worse, I can hear the thoughts of their attackers, and they seem to be hunting for someone. For me...Categorized as:
reverse-harem paranormal multi-pov fated-mates polyamory romance fiction young-adult -
![Dragonfly by Calliope Stewart]()
Dragonfly by Calliope Stewart
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsA wingless gargoyle, a woman on the run, and a tattoo parlor turned sanctuary. Cashiel Two-hundred years ago Cashiel “Cash” Windheart was cast out of his clan, his wings ripped from his back, doomed to a life of isolation as one of the Wingless. Now, he leads a quiet life at the Monstrous Ink tattoo parlor as one of the few monsters who can tattoo stone skin...Categorized as:
paranormal fated-mates witches-wizards stalking reverse-harem dark polyamory romance -
![Chasing Katana by J. Kearston]()
Chasing Katana by J. Kearston
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsShifters are born, not created… Until me.Used to life knocking me down, waking up at the bottom of the food chain is a step up. One I spin to my advantage, much to the annoyance of my overprotective bodyguard, Axel. After all, nobody expects a rabbit to rob them blind. Especially not the notorious Viper DeLuca...Categorized as:
paranormal reverse-harem fated-mates multi-pov polyamory romance shapeshifters dragons -
![Delightfully Charmed by Lyra Winters]()
Delightfully Charmed by Lyra Winters
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsOne mage’s curse was another mage’s gift.The worst burden of my immortality was that being alone hurt less than the pain of losing the ones I loved. That changed after five charming mages crashed into my life, and I craved what I never let myself want; a life with them.Not only did I break their hexes, but I accidentally bound their souls to mine—sharing my curse of immortality with each of them...Categorized as:
reverse-harem paranormal fated-mates witches-wizards dark stalking polyamory romance -
-
![Pretentious by Elle Lincoln]()
Pretentious by Elle Lincoln
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsDouble, double toil, I’m in so much trouble.Fire burn, and cauldron crumble... Pepper O’Malley, headmistress… No, no that’s not it.Keymaster, yes I am the keymaster… No that isn’t quite it either. I think I’m getting close.Peace keeper! That’s the one.New Peacekeeper of the Philadelphia region, and I’ve already fallen prey to one slimy criminal that remains elusive... -
![For Dear Life by L.J. Swallow]()
For Dear Life by L.J. Swallow
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsI expected the guys to assist me in solving the Thornwood Academy murders, not add a new victim to the body count. Following events at the lodge and my unfortunate encounter with the fence post, I've no choice but to turn to my father for help. Of course, my blood-covered entourage of guys don't exactly receive a warm welcome, but at least Grayson walks away in one piece...Categorized as:
reverse-harem paranormal witches-wizards polyamory romance vampires urban-fantasy shapeshifters -
![Revenge of Her Wolves by Tara West]()
Revenge of Her Wolves by Tara West
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsFour shattered hearts. Three deadly enemies. Two innocents lost. One chance at peace. Though my identity has been revealed, I’m left with more questions than answers...Categorized as:
reverse-harem paranormal witches-wizards polyamory romance shapeshifters magic fantasy -
![Wicked Schemes by Amy Oliveira, Santana Knox]()
Wicked Schemes by Amy Oliveira, Santana Knox
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsTHE GODS HAVE WAGED A WAR IN HER NAME, A FATE SHE NEVER DREAMT REFUSING.The first nightmare I can remember was not my own.To be born with power is to be gifted, but all I know is a curse.I am Florencia Morales, one of the seven witches whose fate was woven long before we were born.Marriage was never my dream, never a desire or a goal...Categorized as:
witches-wizards dark fated-mates reverse-harem paranormal multi-pov polyamory romance -
![This Fate That Guides Us: The Primordial Covenant Duet Part One by J.C. Belenac]()
This Fate That Guides Us: The Primordial Covenant Duet Part One by J.C. Belenac
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsWhen the photography job of her dreams falls into Omen Powell’s lap, she finds herself face to face with the band she’s spent the last year fantasizing about.Primordial Covenant, the masked musicians whose sultry melodies and poetic lyrics have taken the music world by storm.Meeting the men behind the masks, their comforting scents and easy affection turn her life upside down... -
![Claimed by the Damned by D.V. Fischer, Amanda K. Mann]()
Claimed by the Damned by D.V. Fischer, Amanda K. Mann
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 6 ratingsDon't run from us, little bunny. Amara is just trying to survive, keeping her head down while simultaneously trying to stay away from her pack’s territory and her abusive alpha father as much as possible. So, when she discovers that she has not one, but three mates and that they are all rogues, it really turns her life upside down...Categorized as:
reverse-harem paranormal fated-mates polyamory romance shapeshifters fantasy season-autumn -
![Owned by the Berserkers by Lee Savino]()
Owned by the Berserkers by Lee Savino
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsMy life changed the night the Berserkers took me. Dagg and Svein cared for me like no other--until the Corpse King attacked and the battle rage took their minds. Now I'm alone. My mates are lost to madness, and my visions are growing worse. My nightmares, my only companions--unless I can defy the pack and save my warriors... -
![Witches Be Crazy by A.J. Macey, Jarica James]()
Witches Be Crazy by A.J. Macey, Jarica James
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsNothing in Aris Calisto’s life has ever been basic, and after a cauldron full of unexpected events, she finds herself a fugitive. Going on the run should have been the biggest challenge of her life, but after being separated from her tethers, she’s faced with an impossible choice--submit or run.With time ticking down, Aris and her ragtag band of witches have to risk it all...Categorized as:
fated-mates multi-pov paranormal polyamory reverse-harem witches-wizards book fiction -
![Cursed Mate by Callie Rose]()
Cursed Mate by Callie Rose
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsThe shadows are winning. Quinton is winning.For years, I hunted my mates with unwavering determination, certain they were my enemies. When they broke the bond and left me shattered and alone on a mountaintop, I vowed to kill them for their betrayal.Then… something changed.They chose me over their allegiance to their alpha.They saved me.They fought for me.They risked everything for me... -
![Moon Child by Serena Akeroyd]()
Moon Child by Serena Akeroyd
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsEli:A goddess told me my child would change the pack. Until it happened, I didn't believe it. Not until I saw it with my own eyes. My woman is a nurturer. She's a bringer of change. A broker of the future. She deals with emotions, sees auras, and glories in the urges of her three alpha mates.To me, she's the saint.But that doesn't make me or my brothers sinners... -
-
![Fox Undercover by Maya Nicole]()
Fox Undercover by Maya Nicole
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsI'm a fox in a wolves' den.My assignment was simple: go undercover and report back about wolf sightings in the area.Instead, I found myself in much deeper with the wolves of Crescent Valley than I'd ever imagined. Lone wolves are mixed up with dangerous humans who know our secret, and it could put all shifters at risk... -
![Phoenix Burn by Ellie Horn]()
Phoenix Burn by Ellie Horn
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsI have a werewolf panting after me, but it turns out I need more than him...Dragons and Unicorns sizzle through my dreams—and apparently...I am not just hormonal. I am also deadly...The completed Warrior Hearts Academy Phoenix trilogy is a dark, slow-burn, paranormal/fantasy romance where the strong female main character has many love interests that she doesn’t have to choose between...Categorized as:
paranormal reverse-harem fated-mates polyamory romance fantasy shapeshifters dragons -
![Rejected by Dragons by Dizzy Hooper]()
Rejected by Dragons by Dizzy Hooper
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsAnd here I thought my life couldn’t get any worse…Ever since the Great War, when my parents abandoned me in the Air Dragon Kingdom, I’ve been the punching bag of the royal elites. They hate me because I’m an outsider. I dare to question their rules and the cruelty of their tyrant king.There’s also the small matter of how I’m a dragon shifter who can’t seem to shift.But none of that matters... -
![Marked for the Pack by Traci Lovelot]()
Marked for the Pack by Traci Lovelot
Rated: 4.25 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsThey promised to protect me during my heat. But are any of us ready for what happens afterward? With my old pack hunting me down, a friend and I embark on a desperate plan to keep everyone we care about safe. Along the way, I'll discover secrets about my past and whether I have any hope of ever shifting. My alphas protect me on my journey, even though I didn't ask them to... -
![Untamed Mate by Callie Rose]()
Untamed Mate by Callie Rose
Rated: 4.20 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsWarning: the blurb below contains spoilers for the first book in the series. If you haven't started the series yet, begin with Rejected Mate. *They broke the bond.But they didn’t break me.Although they left me with a gaping hole in my chest, Kian, Malix, and Frost did me a favor when they shattered our bond and left me alone in the mountains.For a moment there, I'd started to trust them... -
![Running on Empty by Sam Hall]()
Running on Empty by Sam Hall
Rated: 4.20 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsI’m the girl next door who looks for love in all the wrong places.Until the day my smoking hot neighbours who’ve always treated me like a little sister rescue me from the men who hurt me.They tend my wounds.They care for me.They make me whole again.And now the gloves are off.They’re my fated mates. And they won’t give me up for anyone...
Or - use our amazing romance book finder to get recommendations based on your favorite content tropes and themes. Mix and match at will.
