Books like 'First Witch'
Readers who enjoyed First Witch by Jane Hinchey also liked the following books featuring the same tropes, story themes, relationship dynamics and character types.
fantasy romance supernatural urban fantasy paranormal vampires witches-wizards magic cozy shapeshifters
-
My Big Fat Witch Wedding by Amanda M. Lee
Rated: 4.75 of 5 stars · 23 ratingsThe big day is finally here.Bay and Landon’s wedding day has arrived.Unfortunately, a tragedy stands in the way of their happily ever after, and it comes in the form of reports of an armed gunman at the local high school. Bay, ghosts at her side, braves the scene to save the kids … and uncovers something horrific.She. The boy with the gun says he needs to find her... -
![Freaky Mage by Amanda M. Lee]()
Freaky Mage by Amanda M. Lee
Rated: 4.69 of 5 stars · 24 ratingsThe members of Mystic Caravan have Georgia on their minds as they land in Savannah … and immediately find trouble.In a city full of ghosts, Poet Parker expects a few magical things to happen, but when an evil cult sacrifices a young woman on the beach next to their camp, things take a turn nobody was expecting. Thankfully, she’s not alone for this fight... -
![Freaky Reapers by Amanda M. Lee]()
Freaky Reapers by Amanda M. Lee
Rated: 4.68 of 5 stars · 24 ratingsPoet Parker put the past behind her. At least she thought she did. Life on the streets wasn’t what she had in mind for her forever and she jumped at the chance to join Mystic Caravan Circus when an invitation was extended. She didn’t look back. That was ten years ago, and now Poet is going back to the exact area she used to haunt … and she’s nervous. The friends she left behind are scattered... -
![Long, Hot, Witchy Summer by Amanda M. Lee]()
Long, Hot, Witchy Summer by Amanda M. Lee
Rated: 4.61 of 5 stars · 27 ratingsLife couldn’t be going much better for Hadley Hunter. She’s living the dream on Moonstone Bay with her boyfriend Galen Blackwood, plotting her next move as a witch for hire, and basically basking in happiness.That all changes when a summer afternoon on the beach turns into a nightmare, an odd creature from the depths of the ocean surfacing and attacking Hadley on the beach... -
-
![A Power of Old by Bella Forrest]()
-
![An Empire of Stones by Bella Forrest]()
An Empire of Stones by Bella Forrest
Rated: 4.57 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsSOME STONES SHOULD BE LEFT UNTURNED.. -
![Pet Psychic Mysteries Boxset Books 5-8 by Erin Johnson]()
Pet Psychic Mysteries Boxset Books 5-8 by Erin Johnson
Rated: 4.70 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsTalking animals. Quirky cases. An enchanting town. This series has it all, like you’ve never read before!Jolene Hartgrave, here! I went from being a top dog lawyer to a hangdog pet psychic in the ruff part of town, all thanks to a pesky curse that gave me the gift of gabbing with animals.But my luck is finally looking up...Categorized as:
paranormal cozy witches-wizards shapeshifters psychics vampires urban-fantasy mystery -
![A Clan of Novaks by Bella Forrest]()
A Clan of Novaks by Bella Forrest
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 16 ratingsA new era has dawned for the Novak clan. An era in which The Shade has become such a fortress that threats to the island are no longer possible. They have become protectors; fighters, warriors, every one a hero. Witness the Novaks in all their strength and in all their glory. In all their love and all their friendship... -
![A World of New by Bella Forrest]()
A World of New by Bella Forrest
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 16 ratings"Because one can't simply fire a Novak.. -
![A Bridge of Stars by Bella Forrest]()
A Bridge of Stars by Bella Forrest
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 16 ratingsThe explosive finale of Ben and River's... -
![Freaky Fangs by Amanda M. Lee]()
Freaky Fangs by Amanda M. Lee
Rated: 4.64 of 5 stars · 23 ratingsMystic Caravan Circus is in flux. Things are shifting in the organization, new faces are joining the fray, and manager Poet Parker isn’t certain how to deal with it. Unfortunately for her, she doesn’t have time to figure it out.Kentucky is on the horizon, and a roadside accident that claims a family has caught Poet’s attention... -
![To Spell with It by Amanda M. Lee]()
To Spell with It by Amanda M. Lee
Rated: 4.57 of 5 stars · 26 ratingsHadley Hunter thinks she’s seen everything – okay, maybe not everything but a lot of things – but she’s never seen a cupid convention.When her good friend Booker’s fellow cupids descend on Moonstone Bay, she thinks it’s going to be fun and games. Instead, it’s mayhem and mystery when a rash of suicides and attempted suicides hit random island residents... -
![The Killer Clown Calamity by Amanda M. Lee]()
The Killer Clown Calamity by Amanda M. Lee
Rated: 4.62 of 5 stars · 23 ratingsCharlie Rhodes’ life is in turmoil. Her relationship with her boyfriend Jack is going well but Casey, the newest member of the Legacy Foundation, has dropped a bombshell and Charlie feels as if things are spinning out of control. While waiting for DNA results to prove (or disprove, for that matter) Casey’s identity, the team gets called out on a weird case... -
![An Hour of Need by Bella Forrest]()
An Hour of Need by Bella Forrest
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsTime is ticking, paths will cross.. -
-
![A King of Shadow by Bella Forrest]()
A King of Shadow by Bella Forrest
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsSECRETS LURK IN THE DARKEST CORNERS...The longer Hazel and her fellow Shadians stay in Nevertide, the more of a mystery the hidden land becomes to them - and when events within Hellswan take a more sinister, disturbing turn, it's becoming harder to know who to trust... -
![A Race of Trials by Bella Forrest]()
A Race of Trials by Bella Forrest
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsA KING SHALL BE CROWNED The race is on for the crown of Hellswan Kingdom, and Hazel and Ruby have been forced to take opposite sides to increase their likelihood of escape.Hazel with Tejus and Ruby with Ash - a situation that could get complicated... especially when hearts are involved.Meanwhile back on Earth, GASP, led by King Derek have finally cracked a mystery.. -
![A Game of Risk by Bella Forrest]()
A Game of Risk by Bella Forrest
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsWith TRUTH comes risk.With LOVE comes sacrifice.. -
![A Sword of Chance by Bella Forrest]()
A Sword of Chance by Bella Forrest
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 14 ratings"It's fight or die in the treacherous land of Nevertide."Prepare to reunite with the Novaks in another heart-pounding adventure... -
![A Dawn of Guardians by Bella Forrest]()
A Dawn of Guardians by Bella Forrest
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsReturn to The Shade and reunite with your favorite characters in a brand new heart-pounding adventure!A Dawn of Guardians is the start of “Season 5”, a thrilling new storyline.New romance to fall in love with.New mysteries to unravel.A new journey to lose yourself in.. -
![Freaky Witches (Mystic Caravan, #7) by Amanda M. Lee]()
Freaky Witches (Mystic Caravan, #7) by Amanda M. Lee
Rated: 4.59 of 5 stars · 23 ratingsMystic Caravan Circus is heading for the Midwest … and their first stop is Michigan. Hemlock Cove to be exact. Poet Parker is looking forward to what she believes will be a quiet time. Hemlock Cove isn’t big, after all, and Mystic Caravan is essentially serving as the centerpiece for a paranormal festival in a town where everyone pretends to be witches... -
![A Trail of Echoes by Bella Forrest]()
A Trail of Echoes by Bella Forrest
Rated: 4.44 of 5 stars · 16 ratings"Something told me that after my weeks trapped in The Oasis, I hadn't even scratched the surface of what really went on there..."What is so different about Ben Novak?Secrets will be unravelled and shocking discoveries will be made in A Trail of Echoes... -
![A Hero of Realms by Bella Forrest]()
A Hero of Realms by Bella Forrest
Rated: 4.44 of 5 stars · 16 ratingsAfter the oracle's prediction of Ben's fate, what options does the Novak have left?Will he attempt to fight his destiny? Can such a battle even be won?Jeramiah still lurks in The Shade like a shadow... -
![Fashionably Dead and Demonic by Robyn Peterman]()
Fashionably Dead and Demonic by Robyn Peterman
Rated: 4.60 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsAnastasiaI’m dead. He’s demonic. It never would have worked…Getting dumped by the Demon of my dreams wasn’t exactly in the game plan. Game plans suck. Throwing caution to the wind is my new motto.I used to be a semi-happily single Vampyre... -
![Freaky Places by Amanda M. Lee]()
Freaky Places by Amanda M. Lee
Rated: 4.56 of 5 stars · 23 ratingsMystic Caravan Circus is heading to the West Coast, and while everyone is happy for the change of scenery there's a pall settling over the group. Poet and Kade are in a good place and planning for a change, but it's something Poet can't focus on because she feels as if someone is watching … and whoever it is has evil in his or her heart... -
-
![A Chase of Prey by Bella Forrest]()
A Chase of Prey by Bella Forrest
Rated: 4.39 of 5 stars · 18 ratings"We need to discover what the twins have. Before it's too late."With a black witch hard on their heels, Caleb and Rose embark on a race against time to escape the heart of the Amazon and make it back to The Shade.Little do they know how much more hangs in the balance than their own survival.. -
![A Spell of Time by Bella Forrest]()
A Spell of Time by Bella Forrest
Rated: 4.39 of 5 stars · 18 ratings"Tick tock. Tick tock..."Derek and Sofia return in the 10th book of A Shade of Vampire series!Time is slipping through the Novaks' fingers like sand. The only witch with the power to save them is already within their reach.But how does one fix what one doesn't know exists?Prepare for a wild ride back to The Shade.. -
![Southern Magic Wedding by Amy Boyles]()
Southern Magic Wedding by Amy Boyles
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 12 ratingsIt’s Pepper's and Axel’s wedding day. Finally, the big day has arrived and the entire town is ready to celebrate. And Pepper is ready, too. She can’t wait to start her new life. The only problem is that suddenly Axel has ex-girlfriends oozing out of the woodwork. Worse, when a spell is cast on Axel the day before the wedding, his future with Pepper becomes murky. Pepper is shattered... -
![Witch Confidential by Lily Harper Hart]()
Witch Confidential by Lily Harper Hart
Rated: 4.59 of 5 stars · 20 ratingsThe Big Easy is about to be buried in big trouble.Again.For Ofelia Archer, that means she’s knee-deep in an investigation … even though she’s not quite sure how she got there.Zach Sully thinks he’s in for an easy night at Ofelia’s speakeasy – maybe a little flirting as a lead-up to a date included – when a scream in a neighboring abandoned building draws his attention... -
![Witch Is the New Black by Lily Harper Hart]()
Witch Is the New Black by Lily Harper Hart
Rated: 4.66 of 5 stars · 17 ratingsOfelia Archer has faced demons, evil witches, and freaky zombies, but nothing could prepare her for the horror of meeting her boyfriend’s mother, Madeline Sully. She thinks she’s ready and able, but she’s really not.For his part, Zacharias “Zach” Sully isn’t any more thrilled by his mother’s visit than his girlfriend. He’s simply better at dealing with Madeline’s brand of madness... -
![Freaky Hearts by Amanda M. Lee]()
Freaky Hearts by Amanda M. Lee
Rated: 4.43 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsPoet Parker his having a rough time of it … and then some. She owes her boss Max Anderson everything for saving her from a life on the streets, but Mystic Caravan’s favorite psychic is struggling because that loyalty caused her to lose a shot at true love... -
![Freaky Lies by Amanda M. Lee]()
Freaky Lies by Amanda M. Lee
Rated: 4.43 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsThe Mystic Caravan Circus is a place of magic and mayhem. Unfortunately for Poet Parker these days, it’s also packed full of lies.It’s been more than a week since she found out an unsightly secret: Her boss Max is her boyfriend’s father. Despite giving Max an ultimatum, he’s yet to tell Kade Denton the truth, and that’s left Parker in a sticky situation... -
![The Dirty Coven by Lily Harper Hart]()
The Dirty Coven by Lily Harper Hart
Rated: 4.43 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsHannah Hickok is at a crossroads in her life. She’s single, out of a job, and living in an apartment she absolutely hates in a suburb of Detroit. All that changes when she receives a registered letter and finds out she’s inherited a performance town.Casper Creek is located in Kentucky, on top of a small mountain, and is fashioned after notorious towns from the old west... -
![Spelldriver by Gina LaManna]()
Spelldriver by Gina LaManna
Rated: 4.43 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsWith a wedding on the horizon and her father tucked safely away in prison, the future is looking bright for Lily Locke. Unfortunately, life on The Isle is never calm for long… and when a Ranger is killed brutally in plain sight, Lily and her fiancé—the renowned Ranger X—find themselves hunting a murderer more ruthless than any they’ve ever encountered before... -
![Freaky Deaky Tiki by Amanda M. Lee]()
Freaky Deaky Tiki by Amanda M. Lee
Rated: 4.52 of 5 stars · 23 ratingsHadley Hunter is learning about life, love … and being a witch. She has a hot and hunky boyfriend, new friends, and family she didn’t know existed until recently. Her plate is full. Life gets even busier when a Detroit grim reaper named Aisling Grimlock hits Moonstone Bay for her honeymoon. Aisling is loud, brash … and pregnant... -
-
![First-Realm Problems by Nova Nelson]()
First-Realm Problems by Nova Nelson
Rated: 4.63 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsA Paranormal Cozy MysteryWhat happens in New Orleans, slays in New Orleans…Psychic Nora Ashcroft is somewhere she never thought she’d see again: her old world. Desperate to bring Tanner and Eva back to Eastwind as soon as possible, she faces a major up-levee battle in New Orleans... -
![Rage by Charlene Hartnady]()
Rage by Charlene Hartnady
Rated: 4.63 of 5 stars · 8 ratingsRage is the fourth book in a series about monsters of all kinds. If you enjoy fated mates, forbidden romance, sassy heroines, and swoon-worthy beast kings who are almost untamable, then this is the series for you.There are stories circling about a lone wolf in a town called Cherokee Hills. Talk of a creature who walks on two legs…a werewolf. I decide to go and investigate this for myself... -
![Reaping by Maggie M. Lily]()
Reaping by Maggie M. Lily
Rated: 4.63 of 5 stars · 8 ratings“Because I love her. Because I don’t like being apart from her.”The thought ran wild through my brain as I waited for death. I knew I was dying; my head had been sliced off. There was no surviving that kind of nonsense.But my brothers kept shouting and swearing at me. I heard someone crying.Then, I sighed, interrupting my own Shakespearean tragedy vibe.And now there’s someone at the damn door... -
![A Shade of Kiev 3 by Bella Forrest]()
A Shade of Kiev 3 by Bella Forrest
Rated: 4.38 of 5 stars · 16 ratingsThe greatly anticipated finale to Kiev's stand-alone trilogy!After all that's happened, I thought I was past being surprised by Mona. But standing here by the lake, I realize I've barely scratched the surface. Her soul is blacker than I could have imagined. I thought I sought redemption. But now, I wonder if this darkness is what attracted me to her all along.. -
![Curse a Brew Streak by Lily Harper Hart]()
Curse a Brew Streak by Lily Harper Hart
Rated: 4.62 of 5 stars · 17 ratingsOfelia Archer is living the dream … or as close as seemingly possible.She owns her own business, her father seems to be on an even keel, and her new relationship with Detective Zacharias Sully is cruising right along. Everything changes in an instant, though, when screams from the street lead to zombies running amok through the French Quarter... -
![A Shade of Doubt by Bella Forrest]()
A Shade of Doubt by Bella Forrest
Rated: 4.33 of 5 stars · 18 ratings"Love. It's a flickering flame. So easily swayed by doubt..." Unwilling to even grant the two white witches a reception, Derek orders Mona to expel them from the island the moment he hears of their arrival. But will that be enough to rid themselves of their presence? Meanwhile, Rose and Caleb have met with an unexpected hurdle in returning to The Shade... -
![Waking of the Witch by Deanna Chase]()
Waking of the Witch by Deanna Chase
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsGeorgia Exler has always been the odd witch out. In a family of accomplished witches, she’s the only one who never uncovered her own magical abilities… until she moved to Keating Hollow. Heartbroken after her husband of two years is killed in a tragic accident, the writer moves to the enchanted town to start over. All she wants to do is write her next book and make a few new friends... -
![Southern Omens by Amy Boyles]()
Southern Omens by Amy Boyles
Rated: 4.50 of 5 stars · 10 ratingsPepper in her first trimester...and what a trimester it is!All of Magnolia Cove is buzzing when soothsayers arrive to offer blessings to Pepper's and Axel's unborn child. But when one of the soothsayers foresees death, the celebration quickly turns sour.Don't worry because there is a solution... -
![Dead Witches Tell No Tales (The Hollows, #3-4) by Kim Harrison]()
Dead Witches Tell No Tales (The Hollows, #3-4) by Kim Harrison
Rated: 4.42 of 5 stars · 12 ratingsEven in the Holllows - Cincinnati's home to all supernatural folk - vampires and werewolves can make strange bedfellows. Just ask Rachel Morgan, private investigator and witch. First her never-do-well boyfriend disappears into the night. Then the hunky protege of vampire crimelord Piscary starts eyeing her curves... not to mention her throat... -
![Southern Fortunes by Amy Boyles]()
Southern Fortunes by Amy Boyles
Rated: 4.42 of 5 stars · 12 ratingsWhen Pepper teaches a class at the Southern School of Magic, she expects a run of the mill experience. But when a gaggle of mean teachers invades her classroom, Pepper is on high alert.These women are nasty and they make no bones about disliking Pepper... -
-
![Freaky Games by Amanda M. Lee]()
Freaky Games by Amanda M. Lee
Rated: 4.46 of 5 stars · 23 ratingsLook out Sin City, here comes the Mystic Caravan Circus. The city that never sleeps has something lurking in the darkness and Poet Parker can’t decide if it’s friend or foe. The rich history of the area comes into play when research uncovers a mine disaster more than a hundred years in the past … and a tragic outcome that still haunts the locale to this day... -
![A Fork of Paths by Bella Forrest]()
A Fork of Paths by Bella Forrest
Rated: 4.31 of 5 stars · 16 ratings"That vial of potion may have given me life... But what kind of life is this?"As we gear up for Ben and River's explosive finale in Book 24, heart-pounding adventure, challenged love, and thrilling discoveries await you in A Fork of Paths.. -
![A Vial of Life by Bella Forrest]()
A Vial of Life by Bella Forrest
Rated: 4.31 of 5 stars · 16 ratingsThe blue vial gifted by Arron may have granted Ben a reprieve from the Elders, but what is to become of him now?What caused his companion to betray him so viciously?What actually happened on Derek and Sofia's mission with the dragons? Find out these answers and much, much more in A Vial of Life.. -
![A Shade of Kiev 2 by Bella Forrest]()
A Shade of Kiev 2 by Bella Forrest
Rated: 4.31 of 5 stars · 16 ratingsThere is much about my past that I have never revealed to anyone.Nobody knows that, before I lost myself, I was a physician's apprentice.I have witnessed countless human illnesses.But I have lived for centuries and never come across a vampire being sick with anything other than his own darkness.Until today.I'm staring at my blood on the floor and a raging migraine is taking hold of me... -
![Cold as a Witch's Tequila Sunrise by Lily Harper Hart]()
Cold as a Witch's Tequila Sunrise by Lily Harper Hart
Rated: 4.64 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsThe big day has arrived. Hali Waverly is finally getting the surgery she so desperately needs. Her boyfriend Gray Hunter is determined to be by her side for it. She thinks she’s ready for it. Is she, though?The surgery itself goes off without a hitch. Hali’s recovery is another story. Ceding control of her beloved tiki bar to her brother and her boyfriend’s brother only amps up her anxiety... -
![Witches of the Deep by Lily Harper Hart]()
Witches of the Deep by Lily Harper Hart
Rated: 4.64 of 5 stars · 14 ratingsHali Waverly thought she’d seen the worst the world had to offer. Then her boyfriend Gray Hunter’s parents arrived on her beach. Now the horror truly begins.Hali has a big problem…and that’s not including the skeletons that are taking over the beach thanks to an errant spell.Nobody knows who cast the spell, or more importantly why, but Hali is determined to find out...
Or - use our amazing romance book finder to get recommendations based on your favorite content tropes and themes. Mix and match at will.
